top of page

Camera On or Camera Off? The Psychology Behind Zoom Fatigue

11 minutes ago
3 min read

We’ve all been there. You’ve had back-to-back video calls all morning, and when you finally put your headphones down, you’re feeling impossibly drained, in a completely different way than you would after a morning of speaking to people in the office. This is the effect known as Zoom Fatigue, but why does it happen, and does it mean we should all turn our cameras off?


Video calls have transformed the way we work, making it much easier for remote teams to connect and collaborate, but since they became such an integral part of our working lives, researchers have been looking into their effect on our brains. Here are just a few of their findings:

 

All eyes on you

In 2021, Stanford professor Jeremy Bailenson proposed the idea of nonverbal overload. He argued that video conferencing creates several unusual psychological demands, including prolonged close-up eye contact and a reduced ability to look away.


Think about a normal conversation. While eye contact may be polite, it’s normal to glance away to make some notes or look around the room, and in a group setting, usually everyone would only look at you when you choose to speak. Video calls create the experience of everyone watching you all the time - imagine how jarring that would feel in person.


This can feel even more intense if you are using a larger screen, as it feels like the others on the call are physically close to you. Bailenson noted that normally when we are forced to stand near people (for example when we’re inside a lift) we tend to avert our gaze, but this isn’t possible on a screen, so it can feel overwhelming keeping eye contact with people who appear so close.   

 

Staring at yourself

Then there’s the small matter of seeing your own face too – having live, constant feedback of exactly how you look to everyone else on the call.  


Research involving 10,591 participants found that “mirror anxiety”, the discomfort associated with continually seeing your own image, was one of several mechanisms associated with higher levels of video-call fatigue.


Seeing what we look like encourages us to monitor ourselves alongside everything else we're trying to do, sometimes exaggerating our responses to show our attention and being hyper aware of our appearance.


Am I looking interested?

Should I nod?

Was that too much nodding?

Suddenly, listening to a simple quarterly update has become a multitasking exercise.

 

Now it’s quantifiable

We’ve even developed a Zoom Exhaustion & Fatigue Scale, or ZEF Scale, to measure the phenomenon, with five different dimensions of fatigue:


  1. General

  2. Social

  3. Emotional

  4. Visual

  5. Motivational 


Unsurprisingly, higher meeting frequency and longer meetings were consistently associated with feeling significantly more drained.


Another interesting finding: a higher level of fatigue was linked with a “more negative attitude” towards video calls, a key consideration when trying to keep morale and sentiment as positive as possible.  

 

So, what's the argument for cameras ON?

Despite all of this, being able to see others on a call has clear and genuine advantages:


They help the speaker

They can make conversations feel more natural and provide visual feedback to whoever is speaking. This can be critical when addressing large numbers of people – seeing expressions turn more positive, negative or confused allows you to adapt or tackle issues in real time without having to wait for someone to jump in.


They foster connection

For colleagues who rarely share a physical workplace, seeing one another can help virtual interactions feel more personal, helping us build relationships with our colleagues.


They build engagement

Introductions, workshops and small team collaborative sessions are all situations where seeing people's faces makes a massive difference to the feel and flow of the exercise.  

  

Rather than debating whether cameras should always be on or always be off, the psychology suggests a better question:


Does seeing everyone improve this particular conversation?

Consider how many people are on the call, what is being discussed, how long the call will be and what is the value-add of seeing everyone’s faces?


We can also control our own experience. Tempting as it is to see how you look, try minimising or hiding your self-view, even for just part of the call. While it is useful to see what everyone is thinking, occasionally switching away from gallery view may also help with the feeling of being watched.

 

The bottom line

The psychology of video conferencing doesn't tell us to abandon cameras altogether. Instead, it suggests that being permanently visible comes with a cognitive cost that we shouldn't ignore.


Cameras can be fantastic for connection and those conversations where seeing another human face truly matters, but they don't have to be the default for every meeting.


Perhaps the healthiest approach to hybrid working is simply to be more intentional about when and why they are on, and how we can manage our own screens while in a video call for the most positive and least draining experience.


 

Comments


© 2017 Henigan Workplace Consulting | All rights reserved

bottom of page